Your bathtub has a crack, or the glaze is worn and dull, or you just want something different. What do you do? Three main options exist: repair/refinish the existing tub, or replace it entirely. Each has different costs, different longevity, and different results.
This guide compares the costs and outcomes so you can make the right choice for your bathroom.
Option 1: Bathtub Repair — $200–$500
For small cracks, chips, or surface damage, repair is the cheapest option. A professional can fill small cracks with epoxy or fiberglass compound, refinish the area, and restore appearance.
Best for: Small chips or minor surface damage. Longevity: 5–10 years depending on use. Cost: $200–$500. Downside: Repair is temporary. If your tub has structural damage, repair is just prolonging the inevitable.
Option 2: Bathtub Refinishing (Reglazing) — $300–$600
Refinishing strips the old glaze, repairs surface damage, and applies a new protective coating. This makes an old, dull tub look brand new again.
Process: Clean the tub thoroughly. Mask off surrounding areas. Fill chips or cracks. Sand the entire surface. Apply bonding agent. Apply new acrylic or epoxy glaze. Allow to cure 24–48 hours before use.
Best for: Cosmetic restoration. Old, dull tubs that still have structural integrity. Longevity: 5–10 years. Cost: $300–$600. Result: Your tub looks like new. Downside: Refinishing doesn't address structural issues. If your tub has cracks that go through the glaze into the cast iron, refinishing won't solve the problem.
Option 3: Bathtub Replacement — $2,500–$5,000+
Complete tub removal and new tub installation. This is the permanent solution and the most expensive option.
Standard Alcove Tub Replacement — $2,500–$3,500
Remove old tub. Install new acrylic or fiberglass alcove tub in the same location. Standard size, standard configuration.
- Old tub removal and disposal: $300–$500
- New alcove tub: $800–$1,500
- Plumbing adjustments: $400–$700
- Installation labor: $600–$1,000
- Surround and trim work: $400–$800
Freestanding Soaking Tub Replacement — $4,000–$7,000+
Install a luxury freestanding soaking tub as a centerpiece. Dramatically changes the bathroom aesthetic.
- Old tub removal: $300–$500
- Freestanding tub: $1,500–$3,500
- Flooring work for proper placement: $500–$1,000
- Plumbing (supply/drain relocation): $600–$1,200
- Installation and finishing: $1,000–$2,000
Jetted or Air Tub Replacement — $3,500–$6,000+
Install a therapeutic jetted or air bath tub for spa-like relaxation.
- Old tub removal: $300–$500
- Jetted/air tub: $1,500–$2,500
- Electrical work for jets or blower: $400–$800
- Plumbing adjustments: $500–$900
- Installation and finishing: $700–$1,300
Luxury master bathroom with high-end freestanding soaking tub
Evaluate Your Bathtub Options
Not sure whether to repair, refinish, or replace your bathtub? Mastaba can assess your tub and recommend the best option for your situation and budget. Call for a free consultation.
Call (518) 308-6427 →Repair vs. Refinish vs. Replace: Decision Framework
Choose Repair if:
- Damage is minor (small chip or crack)
- Tub is otherwise in good condition
- You want the cheapest immediate solution
Choose Refinishing if:
- Tub is dull or discolored
- Surface has light damage
- Structural integrity is intact
- You want a dramatic cosmetic improvement on a budget
- You want to stay in the home 5–10 more years
Choose Replacement if:
- Tub has structural damage (cracks through the shell)
- Tub is leaking
- You want a different style or material
- Tub is 25+ years old
- You want a permanent solution
- You're planning to stay long-term or sell
Types of Replacement Tubs
Acrylic Tubs
Most common and affordable. Lightweight, easy to install, good insulation. Cost: $800–$1,500. Lifespan: 15–20 years. Prone to scratching over time.
Fiberglass Tubs
Budget option. Lightweight, inexpensive. Cost: $500–$1,000. Lifespan: 10–15 years. Less durable than acrylic.
Cast Iron Enameled Tubs
Premium option. Heavy, durable, classic look. Cost: $1,500–$3,000. Lifespan: 30–50+ years. Requires reinforced flooring for support.
Stone or Concrete Tubs
Ultra-premium option. Custom designs, luxury materials. Cost: $3,000–$8,000+. Lifespan: 40+ years. Heavy; requires professional installation.
Related Articles
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does bathtub replacement cost?
Bathtub replacement costs $2,500–$5,000+ depending on tub style and material. Standard alcove tubs cost $2,500–$3,500. Freestanding or soaking tubs cost $4,000–$6,000+. Costs include removal, new plumbing, and installation.
Is it cheaper to refinish a tub or replace it?
Refinishing a bathtub costs $300–$600, significantly cheaper than replacement ($2,500–$5,000). However, refinishing lasts 5–10 years. Replacement is permanent. If your tub has structural damage, replacement is necessary.
What is the cost of bathtub reglazing?
Bathtub reglazing (refinishing) costs $300–$600. The process involves filling chips, sanding, applying bonding agent, and applying new glaze. Results last 5–10 years depending on use and maintenance.
Should I repair or replace my bathtub?
Repair or refinish if: cracks are minor, structural integrity is intact, you want short-term solution. Replace if: major structural damage, cracks are spreading, tub is 20+ years old, you want a new style or material.
How long does bathtub replacement take?
Bathtub removal and installation typically takes 1–2 days. If you're also updating tile or surround, add 3–5 days.
What types of bathtubs are available?
Common types: standard alcove tub (budget-friendly, fits standard space), freestanding soaking tub (luxury, centerpiece), corner soaking tub (space-efficient), jetted or air tubs (therapeutic). Freestanding tubs cost $1,000–$3,000+ for the tub alone.